FDog Food Labels
English

Home › Guaranteed analysis

The guaranteed analysis, and the conversion that makes it honest

Short answerEvery dog food label guarantees four numbers: minimum crude protein, minimum crude fat, maximum crude fiber and maximum moisture. They are listed "as fed" - water included - which makes wet and dry foods impossible to compare directly. FDA's own worked example shows why the conversion matters: a canned food guaranteeing 12% protein at 78% moisture works out to about 54.5% protein on a dry matter basis, while a dry food guaranteeing 37% protein at 12% moisture works out to about 42%. The can that looked three times weaker comes out higher once converted - an estimate from the label guarantees, not exact composition and not a guaranteed dry-matter floor. Convert before you compare - and remember that guarantees are floors and ceilings, not exact contents.

Source: US FDA, "Complete and Balanced Pet Food", linked at the end.

What each guarantee means

Crude protein (min)The floor, not the exact amount. "Crude" refers to the measurement method (estimated from nitrogen), not quality.
Crude fat (min)Again a floor. Fat is the main driver of calories, so the fat floor hints at energy density.
Crude fiber (max)A ceiling. Higher fiber usually means less digestible bulk.
Moisture (max)The water content - and the number you need for the dry matter conversion.

If a label claims the food is "vitamin-enriched" or "contains minerals", the specific vitamins or minerals must also be guaranteed.

The dry matter conversion

FDA's method: subtract the moisture guarantee from 100 to get the dry matter percentage, then divide the nutrient's guarantee by that dry matter percentage and multiply by 100. FDA's published example compares three adult cat foods - the math is identical for dog food, which is why we reproduce it here.

FDA's example (adult cat foods)Canned #1Canned #2Dry food
Protein guarantee on the label12%11%37%
Moisture guarantee78%78%12%
Dry matter (100 - moisture)22%22%88%
Protein, dry matter basis54.5%50%42%

All three in FDA's example clear the 26% dry-matter minimum for adult cat maintenance - but only after conversion can you see that the dry food has the lowest guaranteed protein of the three. Keep the limits in view: the conversion starts from a minimum protein guarantee and a maximum moisture guarantee, so it gives an estimate from the label guarantees on an equal-moisture basis, not a guaranteed dry-matter floor - it does not prove the exact protein content of any one bag, and real recipes can sit above their guarantees. Two products with the same moisture can be compared straight off the label; anything else needs the math. The label decoder does the conversion for you.

What the panel does not tell you

Guarantees are minimums and maximums, not exact contents, and they say nothing about ingredient quality or digestibility - a protein number does not say where the protein came from. For that, read the ingredient list alongside the panel, and check the adequacy statement for the life stage the food is meant for.

Wondering whether this food fits your dog?PawLine gives research-based answers tailored to your dog's breed, age, size and history - including label questions, ingredients and how much to feed.Ask PawLine